
Hayden Hackney 26/27 Analysis: Should Have More Playing Time at Everton
Hayden Hackney joined Everton with a real chance to prove himself in the Premier League after a strong 2025/26 season at Middlesbrough, but his limited role under David Moyes makes me wonder whether Everton are getting the most out of him. He has started just three games and picked up only spare minutes elsewhere, yet anyone watching can see the quality.
His goal and assist in the Carabao Cup win over Newcastle United showed he can change a game without a steady run in the side. So here is my question for Everton: why not give Hackney more chances to start?
Why Does Hackney Deserve a Bigger Role at Everton?
The main reason I want Hackney playing more is that he affects the game in more than one way. At Middlesbrough, he showed he is not just a midfielder who keeps possession, because he contributes in both attacking and defensive phases.

Source: FotMob
What I like most is that he does a bit of everything. He creates, he carries the ball and he puts a foot in, and creating 83 chances while completing 54 dribbles tells me he can hurt teams with a pass or by running past people himself.
That has carried over to Everton, where he averages 86.2 touches per 90 minutes, the most at the club among players with at least 100 minutes across competitions. That is a midfielder who wants the ball, and Everton need players like that instead of ones who wait for a teammate to start the attack. Hackney has already shown he is that type, which for me makes a strong case for a more consistent role.
Can Hackney Improve Everton's Midfield Progression?
Yes, and this is the part of his game Everton needs most. At Middlesbrough under Kim Hellberg, Hackney showed he can receive under pressure, turn away from opponents and move the ball into advanced areas, which is valuable against sides that press and try to stop midfielders receiving comfortably. His 4.15 progressive carries per 90 minutes were the highest figure among midfielders in England's second tier.
His build-up movement stands out too. He drops deep for the centre-backs, scans before receiving and uses his body to escape pressure, and one Middlesbrough example sums it up: he took the ball from the centre-backs, turned out of the press, carried it forward and slipped a disguised through pass into the final third.
For Everton, that means another way to move the ball up the pitch. Instead of relying on wide players, Hackney can link defence and attack through the centre, giving Everton another way to break down compact defensive blocks.
Could Hackney Become Everton's Left-Sided Attacking Midfielder?
Yes, I think he could, especially given how thin Everton look out wide right now. Jack Grealish is suspended for breaching club discipline, and while Tyrique George, Brennan Johnson and Tyler Dibling are still available, relying on them to perform consistently in the Premier League feels like a risk. That gives Moyes a reason to try something different instead of depending entirely on traditional wingers.
Hackney gives Everton something different, because at Middlesbrough under Kim Hellberg he would drift from midfield into wide areas whenever the team pushed up, and I believe that works at Everton if he starts on the left and cuts inside with the ball. There is no need for him to hug the touchline. Instead, he can operate in the left half-space, link up with teammates and create an extra man in central areas while still tracking runners and covering the left side.
It would look a lot like how Unai Emery uses central midfielders such as John McGinn in wider attacking roles at Aston Villa. For Moyes, using Hackney in this role would add tactical flexibility and reduce Everton's reliance on inexperienced wide players.
Can Everton Afford His Defensive Weaknesses?
They can, but only if they cover for him. I think his defensive work is the main thing holding him back from becoming a reliable Premier League starter. His numbers were below average compared with other central midfielders in the selected dataset, including just 0.70 interceptions per 90 last season. His ability to read opposition passes, intercept the ball and protect central areas still needs improvement.
That does not mean he is lazy, because his strengths are simply tied more to controlling possession than to breaking up opposition attacks. The worry gets bigger when you factor in how fast Premier League transitions are, since Championship opponents often give you the time and space to recover your position, while Premier League teams will punish even a small positioning mistake.
Building the Right Partnership: Who Should Play Alongside Hackney?
James Garner is the partner I would pick, because Hackney's effectiveness depends partly on the midfield structure around him, and I would be far more comfortable seeing him next to someone with defensive discipline than alongside another player who wants to push forward. Garner's defensive contributions and ability to maintain the midfield structure could cover for some of Hackney's weaknesses when Everton lose possession.
|
Position |
Player |
Main responsibility |
|
Central midfield |
James Garner |
Defensive coverage and ball recovery |
|
Central midfield |
Hayden Hackney |
Build-up and progression |
|
Attacking midfield |
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall |
Forward movement and attacking support |
That setup allows Hackney to focus on progressing the ball without taking full responsibility for protecting the midfield. Dewsbury-Hall can provide forward runs and attacking combinations, although Moyes would need to ensure their positioning does not overlap too much.
Of course, I would not necessarily expect this combination to work immediately, but it provides a reasonable starting point for experimentation.
Why Is Hackney Ready to Compete at Premier League Level?
Many players struggle to make the jump from the Championship to the Premier League, but Hackney has already shown encouraging signs in his first season at Everton. He has not nailed down a starting spot yet, but his performances in limited chances suggest he can compete at this level.
He made his Premier League debut against Crystal Palace, starting the match and playing around 79 minutes. His best showing, though, came in the Carabao Cup fourth-round win over Newcastle United. He started in midfield, scored once and provided an assist in Everton's 3-1 victory, demonstrating his attacking influence and ability to perform in a major knockout match. He also had a decent cameo against Arsenal, coming on for Mykolenko in the 74th minute.
Moyes may not have to ease Hackney into Premier League football for much longer, and maybe he did not need to from the start. That performance against Newcastle could earn him more minutes in more meaningful situations, and Everton would only benefit from that.
Hayden Hackney vs Coventry City: What Changes If He Plays?
It is difficult to predict how much playing time Hackney will get, but if he features, his ability to progress the ball and link midfield with attack could influence Everton's overall approach and create opportunities in several betting markets.
|
Market |
|||
|
Hayden Hackney – 1+ Fouls Committed |
Note: Odds are accurate as of 4 Nov 2026.
His attacking play is not the only thing worth looking at here. This market is worth considering because it reflects Hackney's defensive responsibilities and involvement in midfield duels. He committed six fouls in just 65 minutes during Everton's Carabao Cup win over Newcastle United, suggesting that he can be heavily involved in physical midfield battles.
Coventry City add to that picture, since they committed 16 fouls in their recent 3-1 win over Sunderland, so their matches clearly come with plenty of physical intensity. If Hackney starts against Coventry, he may be the one asked to break up their attacking transitions, especially when their midfielders try to move the ball forward quickly. That is exactly the kind of job that puts him in positions where he has to make a tactical challenge to stop a counter-attack.
|
Market |
Dafabet Best Odds |
DK88 Best Odds |
Shuffle Best Odds |
Note: Odds are accurate as of 4 Nov 2026.
Everton have scored nine goals in nine Premier League matches this season, averaging one per game. That is not exactly thrilling, but they have still found the net in three of their last four home league games, so the record is not bad. Coventry, for their part, have failed to score in two of their last four away league matches.
If Hackney gets more minutes, he could improve Everton's ball progression, create more space for attackers like Dewsbury-Hall and reduce their reliance on wide attacks by providing better connections through central midfield.

About the Author
Dan - GoalBible Maestro
Sports Betting Odds Analyst
I spent 8 years inside the Asian sportsbook industry — first as a Sports Trader at Opus Gaming Software Ltd in Makati, then as promoted to Event Settler / Live Sports Trader, and eventually became the Senior Sports Trader & Risk Manager at Offside Gaming in Philippines. In that time, I watched tens of thousands of lines get set, moved, and exploited. I saw which bettors the books respected and which ones they didn't. I learned that the market tells you something every single day.
More articles by Dan - GoalBible Maestro